Research Excellence Framework (REF)
In REF2014 Loughborough was ranked a top ten research University in the Times Higher Education (THE) intensity rankings. We are now preparing for our REF2021 submission.
What is the REF?
The Research Excellence Framework assesses the quality of research in UK Higher Education Institutions. The next REF will be assessed in 2021, across 34 subject based Units of Assessment (UoA). The REF informs the selective annual allocation of funding for the period between exercises (c. 6 years), awarded by the four UK higher education bodies. The assessment provides accountability for public investment in research and produces evidence of the benefits of this research in the form of case studies.
In REF2021 three main areas will be independently assessed by UoA Panels; analysis of outputs (60%), impact (25%) and research environment (15%). In 2014, quality ratings for all three sub-sections led to an Overall Quality profile for each UoA submitted. Loughborough University made 18 submissions to 17 UoAs. For further detail on how we performed in 2014 see the REF2014 website.
REF Code of Practice
All higher education institutions who intend to make a submission to the 2021 Research Excellence Framework (REF) are required to develop, document and apply a Code of Practice on the fair and transparent identification of staff and selection of outputs for REF submission.
Loughborough University’s Code of Practice is being drafted by a working group chaired by the Pro-Vice Chancellor (Research) and consisting of academic staff, Human Resources, Loughborough UCU, the Planning Team, and the Research Office. The draft Code of Practice will be made available on this webpage from 27 March, when feedback is invited until 1 May 2019. The final Code of Practice has to be submitted by 7 June.
Feedback should be emailed to the Research Policy Team at firstname.lastname@example.org or by telephone: 01509 228594
Following the 2014 Research Excellence Framework, Lord Stern performed an independent review of the exercise to which Loughborough University responded. Following Lord Stern’s report, HEFCE published a consultation on some proposed changes to the REF.
The key decisions include:
- All staff with a significant responsibility for research should be submitted.
- The average number of outputs per member of staff submitted should be 2.5 with a minimum of 0 (where staff have individual circumstances) and a maximum of 5.
- This may include outputs of staff who no longer work at Loughborough University as long as they were demonstrably generated here.
- Each submission should include a total of two case studies (up to 19.99 FTE), plus one additional case study for up to 15 FTE….
Sub-panel Chairs were announced in December 2017.
REF Support Structures at Loughborough
Loughborough University Submission to REF (LUSTRE)
LUSTRE meetings are scheduled for the Spring 2019 and 2020. All REF UoA Teams will receive guidance on their progress from internal and external advisors including PVC(R), PVC(E), REF Panel reps, senior staff, Research Policy and Planning, Planning Team. Chair: PVC(R). Contact: Elizabeth Gadd & Angela Crawford, Research Office. Email: email@example.com
Code of Practice Working Group
The Code of Practice Working Group is a short-term working group established to steer, design and implement the University's REF Code of Practice around the identification of staff with significant responsibility for research, those that qualify as independent researchers and the selection of outputs. It is attended by representatives from academic staff, HR, Loughborough UCU, Research Office. Chair: PVC(R). Contact: Elizabeth Gadd, Research Office. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
REF Panel Member Advisory Group
The REF Panel Member Advisory Group consists of Loughborough staff who sit on, or secretary, REF 2021 panels. It meets occassionally to guide the university (within the bounds of confidentiality imposed by the REF) on its submission. Chair: PVC(R). Contact: Angela Crawford, Research Office. Email: email@example.com
Open Access Advisory Working Group (OAAWG)
The Open Access Advisory Working Group exists to oversee the management and operation of the Institutional Repository and LUPIN (LU Publication Information Network) and to advise Research Committee on open access and data matters. It meets quarterly and is attended by representatives from academic staff, library staff, Research Office and IT Services. Chair: Jeff Brown, Assistant Library Director: Support, Collections & Systems. Contact: Katie Appleton and Naomi Dungworth, Library. Email: Repository@lboro.ac.uk
REF OA Action Group
This is an informal group of Library and Research Office staff that meet regularly to discuss operational matters relating to Open Access, the Institutional Repository and LUPIN (LU Publication Information system). Contact: Repository@lboro.ac.uk or firstname.lastname@example.org
REF UoA Teams
Each Unit of Assessment to which Loughborough University intends to submit is supported by a team, headed up by a UoA Lead. Each additional School submitting to a UoA will also have it's own School Lead. UoA Teams are responsible for writing their environment statement, identifying independent researchers, and selecting outputs and case studies for submission in line with Loughborough University's Code of Practice. A list of the UoA Leads and their contact details are below.
|UoA Name||Main Panel||UoA number||Overall Lead|
|Public Health, Health Services and Primary Care||A||2||Mark Hamer|
|Mathematical Sciences||B||10||Andy Archer|
|Computer Science and Informatics||B||11||Qinggang Meng|
|Architecture, Built Environment and Planning||C||13||Malcolm Cook|
|Geography and Environmental Studies||C||14||Louise Holt|
|Business and Management Studies||C||17||Tom Jackson|
|Politics and International Studies||C||19||Caroline Kennedy-Pipe|
|Social Work and Social Policy||C||20||Steve Case|
|Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism||C||24||David Stensel|
|English Language and Literature||D||27||Michael Wilson|
|Art and Design: History, Practice and Theory||D||32||Richard Bibb|
|Communication, Cultural & Media Studies, Library & Information Management||D||34||James Stanyer|
I believe I qualify for a reduction in outputs due to my circumstances, what should I do?
The UK funding bodies are committed to supporting and promoting equality and diversity in research careers. As part of this commitment, measures have been put in place to recognise the effect that individuals’ circumstances may have on research productivity, resulting in a reduction in outputs. Please see paragraph 160 of the REF Guidance on Submissions for a list of circumstances that apply. Loughborough University's Code of Practice Working Group are developing a process by which staff can voluntarily declare any such circumstances. All staff will be notified of this process when it is in place. In the interim, if you have any questions about this, please either contact your UoA Team Lead or the Research Policy Team on email@example.com.