“The campaign to introduce a staggered age for consent has good intentions and it’s fantastic to see so many women speaking up about a genuine gap in current approaches to sexual offence allegations. Power differentials, including those arising from age gaps, need to be acknowledged.
“However, age gaps are only one type of power imbalance. Relationships can also be influenced by status, wealth, workplace hierarchies, social influence and other factors that a staggered age of consent would not address. This is particularly important for communities at greater risk of sexual victimisation.
“The law already defines consent as requiring freedom and capacity to make informed choices about engaging in sexual acts. The question is whether we are doing enough to consider the wider context in which those choices are made.
“Research from Operation Soteria, the national programme designed to improve the investigation of rape and serious sexual offences, highlighted the importance of examining the dynamics of a relationship and a suspect's behaviour, rather than focusing narrowly on the actions of the victim.
“While this approach has increasingly been adopted in policing, there remains debate about how much context is considered in court. That may be where reform efforts should begin.
“Rather than creating new age thresholds, a more effective approach may be to strengthen how existing laws account for power imbalances and vulnerability. The challenge is not simply age difference, but understanding when unequal power affects a person's freedom and capacity to consent.
“It’s important to highlight that any kind of reform needs to listen carefully to what survivors say would have helped them and what changes they believe would make the greatest difference. Public concern can create pressure to act quickly, but it is equally important to pause and consider what we are trying to achieve, and which measures are most likely to improve outcomes for everyone involved.
“Public debate following recent high-profile incidents shows that something needs to change.”
ENDS
For further comments or interview requests from Dr Olivia Smith, please email the PR team or call 01509 222224.
Research links